4 questions every pantry food brand should ask its customers

The exact wording, the answer options, and what to do with the answers. Written for Shopify pantry food brands and ready to copy into your post-purchase survey.

Why ask

What your analytics can’t tell you

Pantry food gets tasted long before it gets ordered online. Someone picks up a jar in a farm shop, finds one in a Christmas hamper, or has it at a hotel breakfast. Years later they order from your website. Your analytics says “Google”.

It can’t tell you whether they’ve eaten your food before, what this order is for, or what they wish you made. You have to ask.

The four questions

Two for new customers, one for returning customers, and one by email once they’ve used the product.

Made for pantry food · Who they are

“Have you tried us before today?”

Answers: No, this is my first time · Yes, from a supermarket · Yes, from a farm shop or deli · Yes, someone gave it to me as a gift · Yes, at a café, hotel or restaurant · Somewhere else

Ask it: thank-you page, first-time customers.

Why these answers: The answers are places, because a place is what people remember. A gift gets its own answer, since plenty of people first taste a brand like yours out of a hamper. “No, this is my first time” comes first so new customers don’t have to hunt for it.

One caveat: people forget. Someone who had your marmalade at a hotel ten years ago will say it’s their first time, so the real number of first-timers is lower than it looks.

What it tells you: whether your website is finding new customers or serving people who already buy you in the shops.

What to do with it

  • Customers who’ve known you for years get a welcome that skips the introduction and shows them the things they can’t get in the shops.
  • First-timers get the story: who you are, how it’s made and where to start.
  • If most of your online customers already buy you in the shops, judge your ads on the new customers they bring, not on total online sales.
  • Pass the list of places to whoever looks after your stockists. It shows which kinds of shop lead to an online order.

What goes wrong in pantry food surveys

  • Treating online customers as new to the brand. Many of them have bought you in the shops for years. Ask before you send a welcome series that introduces you.
  • Mixing “bring it back” with “what’s new”. Asked together, the old favourites win and the new ideas never surface. Ask about discontinued products and new ones separately.
  • Asking gift buyers how it tasted. They didn’t eat it.
  • Asking about every jar in the order. Someone who bought eight things won’t rate eight things. Ask about one.
  • Reading November and December like the rest of the year. Gift orders change who’s buying and why, so compare those months with the same months last year.

The mistakes that apply to any shop, like vague wording and asking without a plan for the answers, are in what to ask customers after purchase.

Who gets asked what, and when

No customer sees more than four questions at once. The three marked “General” are worth asking whatever you sell.

WhoWhen and whereWhat they’re asked
New customersStraight after checkout, on the thank-you page
  1. Have you tried us before today?
  2. What’s this order mainly for?
  3. How did you first hear about us? General
  4. Did anything nearly stop you buying today? General
Returning customersStraight after checkout, on the thank-you page
  1. What would you most like to see from us next?
  2. Did anything nearly stop you buying today? General
All customersAbout a month after delivery, by one-click emailHow likely are you to recommend us to a friend? General
All customersOnce they’ve had time to open it, by one-click emailNow you’ve tried it, would you buy it again?

Pantry food answers for the general questions

How did you first hear about us? A supermarket · A farm shop or deli · A gift or hamper · A café, hotel or restaurant · A friend or family member · Social media · Something else

Did anything nearly stop you buying today? No · Delivery cost · Worried about breakages · Price · Couldn’t find what I wanted · Something else

How likely are you to recommend us to a friend? 0 to 10. Wait until they’ve eaten it, so they’re scoring the food and not the checkout.

How to word these three, and what to do with the answers, is in what to ask customers after purchase.

Ask your own AI Assistant

Connect Grapevine to Claude or ChatGPT with our MCP connector and ask about your answers in plain English. Here are two to try for pantry food. There are more in the prompt library.

  • “What share of first-time online customers had already tried us somewhere else, and where?”

  • “What do returning customers most want to see from us next? Rank the answers.”

How Tiptree does it

Tiptree’s preserves are sold in supermarkets, farm shops, delis and hotels in over seventy countries, which left the team with little view of who their customers were. Their Shopify store changed that. A post-purchase survey asks how customers first heard of Tiptree, what they’ve bought before, what mattered most about their order, and what they’d like to see made next. Over 80% of customers complete it.

“We ask about discontinued products first, so customers can tell us what they would like to see come back. Then we ask about completely new product ideas. That way we capture the nostalgia answers separately and give ourselves the best chance of hearing something genuinely new.” Adam Crichton, E-Commerce Executive

Launch it yourself, or with our help

1. Install Grapevine and add it to your thank-you and order status pages.
2. Build two thank-you page surveys, one for first-time customers and one for returning customers, using display rules.
3. Add two one-click email surveys to your Klaviyo post-purchase flow.
4. Switch on the Klaviyo integration and build your segments from the answers.

Rather have a hand? Tell us what you sell and we’ll help you pick the questions for your range, word the answers and set up who sees what. It’s free, and you’ll be talking to the people who built Grapevine.

Frequently Asked Questions

Four that are specific to pantry food: whether they’ve tried you before, what the order is for, what they’d like you to make next, and whether they’d buy it again. Then add the three worth asking in any shop: how they heard about you, whether anything nearly stopped them buying, and whether they’d recommend you.

Yes. Pantry brands are often discovered in a supermarket, a farm shop or a hamper long before anyone orders online. Knowing which of your online customers are new and which are long-standing fans changes what you send them, and changes how you judge your advertising.

No. New customers get asked whether they’ve tried you before and what the order is for. Returning customers skip those and get asked what they’d like you to make next. The follow-up email asking whether they’d buy it again goes only to people who bought for themselves.

About a month after delivery, once customers have had time to open and eat what they ordered. Asking at checkout tells you how the checkout went, not what they thought of the food. Send it as a one-click email, so customers can answer with a single tap.

Be careful. Allergies and medical diets are health information, and collecting them comes with stricter data protection rules. Preferences like vegetarian or vegan are fine to ask about. Put your allergen details on the product page, where everyone can see them.

Still have questions?

Drop us a message and we will be on hand to help. Whether it's a demo, a few more questions or you just want to speak to someone before installing, we're always happy to chat.